Who Is Your The Summer I Turned Pretty Boyfriend?

Be honest — you already know whether you'd wait three seasons for Conrad to finally say it out loud, or whether Jeremiah's smile would have gotten you on day one.

The Conrad vs. Jeremiah debate has outlasted the show, broken up friend groups, and honestly launched a whole Psychology Today article. That's not a fandom — that's a cultural force.

Here's the thing about people who are obsessed with The Summer I Turned Pretty: you don't just watch it for the beach. You watch it because something about Cousins Beach, the summer house, and the way those boys love hits a nerve about the kind of love you actually want. Whether you're Team Conrad, Team Jeremiah, or secretly rooting for someone the internet hasn't fully appreciated yet — your answer says more about you than you might think.

There are four types here: the brooding slow-burn who makes everything feel worth it once he finally opens up; the golden-retriever sunshine who shows up before you even ask; the overachieving straight-talker who's softer than he looks; and the quietly devoted one who remembers every single thing you've ever said. One of them is undeniably yours. Take the quiz to find out.

⬇ Scroll Down & Take The Quiz ⬇

TSITP Boyfriend Quiz

Pick your ideal Saturday energy

Spontaneous road trip — whoever wants to come, come

Productive morning, social afternoon, you've already scheduled both

A solo beach walk, mostly quiet, maybe a book

Deeply researching something you found accidentally at 11pm

Someone you like has been weirdly distant lately. What do you actually do?

Give them space, but quietly check in on day three with something low-pressure

Show up at their door with snacks and no real plan

Go quiet too and wait to see who cracks first

Spend four days analyzing it, then send a very precise message

Your Cousins Beach vibe would be:

Standing at the edge of the bonfire, watching everyone from a distance

Arriving with a plan and leaving with a much better story

Reading in a hammock until someone asks the right question and suddenly it's two hours later

Organizing an impromptu volleyball game before anyone's even settled

Your group chat is going completely unhinged. You:

Type a long response, delete half of it, send the sharp two-sentence version

React with five emojis and immediately suggest meeting IRL

Drop one perfectly timed, unexpectedly funny reply and disappear again

Read every single message. Say nothing.

Pick a color...

Forest green — sharp, grounded, a little unexpected

Soft blue — calm, cool, quietly interesting

Deep navy — like the ocean at dusk

Golden yellow — like the best summer afternoon

Someone tells you they've had feelings for you for a long time. How does that land?

You're emotional immediately and have to stop yourself from reacting too fast

You're genuinely surprised, even though looking back the signs were obvious

You already knew. You just weren't ready to deal with it yet.

You take it seriously, sit with it, and respond with more thoughtfulness than they expected

The summer house needs someone to plan the big end-of-summer dinner. You:

Vanish before anyone can ask, then quietly contribute the one thing everyone forgot

Volunteer before anyone finishes the sentence

Take charge, delegate efficiently, act like it's not a big deal even though you've been thinking about it for a week

Offer to handle one specific thing and do it better than anyone expected

How do you handle it when you've accidentally hurt someone?

Apologize immediately — maybe too much — and check in again the next day

Think it through carefully, then say exactly what you mean at exactly the right moment

Withdraw, feel terrible in silence, then eventually say something oblique that's actually an apology

Own it directly, because you genuinely can't leave things unresolved

What's your late-night move?

A walk alone while everyone else has already gone to sleep

Falling into a Wikipedia rabbit hole about something completely unrelated to your actual life

Finishing something you promised yourself you'd finish today

Convincing two people to stay up way too late playing a game you made up on the spot

Someone asks how you're doing and you don't really want to answer. You say:

A real but surface-level answer that deflects without technically lying

A slightly too-honest mini-rant about something adjacent to the actual issue

"Fine."

A joke, a laugh, a subject change — all in one smooth move

Which of these sounds most like something you'd actually say?

"Actually, there's something kind of interesting about that, if you want to hear it."

"Come on, it'll be fun. Trust me."

"I'm not saying I told you so, but — I mean, I did."

"I just need a minute."

Your friends are describing you to someone who's never met you. They'd probably say:

"The most fun person — you just can't always predict what you're walking into."

"Intense. Loyal. Impossible to read until suddenly you're completely not."

"Ambitious, occasionally a lot, and usually right about it."

"The kindest person. Also knows a disturbing amount about a very specific thing."

Who Is Your 'Summer I Turned Pretty' Boyfriend?

Your Boyfriend is Conrad Fisher!

You've processed an emotionally devastating book or movie completely alone for months — and only brought it up at 2am during the most intense conversation of your life, like it was nothing. Conrad is the endgame love: bone-deep loyal, achingly perceptive, and the kind of person whose intensity makes you feel like the only one in the room the moment he looks up. Sure, your idea of 'opening up' is a single loaded glance and the quiet hope that the right person will connect the dots without you having to say it out loud — and look, it works, eventually, after two full seasons. That Cousins Beach finale hit the way it did because every silent, storm-clouded look Conrad ever gave felt like it was building to exactly that moment. You are a black cat boyfriend energy in human form, and the right person is going to think that's the most magnetic thing that's ever happened to them.

Your Boyfriend is Jeremiah Fisher!

You are 100% the person who planned the whole surprise before confirming the other person even likes surprises — and then spent three days casually studying their smile to see if it was real. Jeremiah's warmth is genuinely rare: he makes people feel chosen and lit up without even trying, and his love language is showing up so completely that you feel it before he even says a word. Not saying you've ever proposed something life-altering — a trip, a plan, a 'we should just do it' scheme — with the same breezy energy as suggesting brunch, but your friends have definitely learned to ask follow-up questions. The bonfire scenes, the road trips, throwing a whole party just to see someone smile — that's not extra, that's you on a Tuesday. You don't do low-key; you do grand gestures on a Thursday afternoon, and honestly, the world is a better place for it.

Your Boyfriend is Steven Conklin!

You have a detailed five-year plan saved in at least two apps, and you still texted 'idk, we'll see' when someone asked what you're doing this weekend — because the man contains multitudes. Steven is the underrated one: sharp, ambitious, and so much more emotionally layered than his sarcasm lets on, which is why his Season 3 glow-up and his whole arc with Taylor turned out to be one of the most quietly compelling things the show ever did. Your friends MIGHT occasionally describe you as 'the one who says they're not getting involved and then immediately, very thoroughly gets involved' — starting every time with 'I'm not trying to get in your business, but.' You are a diamond in the rough, which means the people who figure you out feel like they've unlocked something genuinely special. Most supportive person in the room, most protective one in the group chat, and somehow always the last to know what's actually happening in your own love life — it's a gift, really.

Your Boyfriend is Cam!

You have an extremely niche passion — something involving deep-sea creatures, a very specific historical era, or a language most people didn't know was a language — and you'll only bring it up if someone asks exactly the right question, but when they do, it's genuinely fascinating. Cam is the underrated sleeper result: effortlessly kind, quietly devoted, and the type of person who shows up exactly as he said he would and remembers the small details weeks later without making it weird. You're conflict-averse enough that you'd let a situation get mildly absurd before saying the one mildly uncomfortable thing that would fix it — not passive, just running a very patient, very kind long game. He showed up at Cousins Beach mid-summer, studied whales in his spare time, spoke multiple languages, and handled not being chosen with more grace than most people manage in their best moments — that kind of quiet dignity is a whole personality. You are genuinely delightful to be in a relationship with, and you are also the last person on earth to send a first text. The whale research can wait. The DM cannot.

Who Is Your The Summer I Turned Pretty Boyfriend?

TSITP Boyfriend Quiz

Pick your ideal Saturday energy

Someone you like has been weirdly distant lately. What do you actually do?

Your Cousins Beach vibe would be:

Your group chat is going completely unhinged. You:

Pick a color...

Someone tells you they've had feelings for you for a long time. How does that land?

The summer house needs someone to plan the big end-of-summer dinner. You:

How do you handle it when you've accidentally hurt someone?

What's your late-night move?

Someone asks how you're doing and you don't really want to answer. You say:

Which of these sounds most like something you'd actually say?

Your friends are describing you to someone who's never met you. They'd probably say:

Other Quizzes About The Summer I Turned Pretty

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Who Is Your The Summer I Turned Pretty Boyfriend?

TSITP Boyfriend Quiz

Pick your ideal Saturday energy

Someone you like has been weirdly distant lately. What do you actually do?

Your Cousins Beach vibe would be:

Your group chat is going completely unhinged. You:

Pick a color...

Someone tells you they've had feelings for you for a long time. How does that land?

The summer house needs someone to plan the big end-of-summer dinner. You:

How do you handle it when you've accidentally hurt someone?

What's your late-night move?

Someone asks how you're doing and you don't really want to answer. You say:

Which of these sounds most like something you'd actually say?

Your friends are describing you to someone who's never met you. They'd probably say:

Which Character Of The Summer I Turned Pretty Are You?

Other Quizzes About The Summer I Turned Pretty

Which Character Of The Summer I Turned Pretty Are You?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply